Ranking Three-Time Survivor Players – Number 6: Aubry Bracco
In a perfect world, Aubry Bracco would have won Survivor: Kaoh Rong and been included on Winners at War (and this is coming from someone who adores Michele). Sadly, Aubry failed to convince the bitter jury in Kaoh Rong that she was deserving of the million bucks and now she’s 0/3 when it comes to trying to win the game.
Aubry played the best game in Kaoh Rong, but every time she’s returned, her stock has gone down quite a bit. She made it to the final five in Game Changers, but we really didn’t get to see a ton from her despite her apparently being a jury threat. She was voted out on Day 37.
Aubry’s third outing was on Edge of Extinction, where she did not do well. She was voted out fifth overall, but didn’t even make it past her first tribal council. It was common knowledge that the newbies didn’t want a returning player to win, so Aubry didn’t have much of a prayer in her third try.
While Aubry deserved to win season 32, she has still yet to secure the victory and has done worse each time, so I can’t put her in the top five.
Ranking Three-Time Survivor Players – Number 5: J.T. Thomas
At one time, J.T. Thomas was one of the best winners the game of Survivor had ever seen for his performance on Tocantins. He played the show’s first perfect game and was able to overcome a 6-3 deficit at the merge to make it to the end.
Unfortunately for J.T., the more he returned, the more his reputation took a hit.
We all remember the decision he made in Heroes vs Villains to give Russell his Hidden Immunity Idol, which eventually got used against him and helped get him booted on Day 27. That decision was named as the dumbest move in Survivor history at the Heroes vs Villains reunion.
J.T.’s third (and likely final) appearance came in Game Changers when he was just a totally different player. He was getting into fights with people (mainly Michaela) and saw his torch snuffed on Day 13 after he played a hand in getting Malcolm booted and people didn’t trust him anymore. He left the game with the Hidden Immunity Idol back at camp.
I respect the heck out of J.T.’s win, but man he sure hurt his stock with his two returning games and that’s why he’s ranked here.