Whether you’ve watched the season premiere ofSurvivor 51or not, by now you’ve heard from the fans scattered across the internet that it was probably the best premiere sinceSurvivor: Winners at War.
With host and showrunnerJeff Probst’spersistent reminder of “Permanent Uncertainty” over the last several months, we really couldn’t have guessed—at least not 100%—what to expect for the kick off of the open era. But, as promised, the show delivered a combination of chaos and classic gameplay elements that created the perfect storm of a first episode, leavingfans wanting more.
So let’s dive into the good, the bad, and the best parts of theSurvivor 51premiere episode, “Permanent Uncertainty.”
What we liked aboutSurvivor 51episode 1
From the very first moment, the editing of the show made it feel like we’re truly going back to basics this season. From leading the player introductions with strategy versus storytelling, the game already feels like we’re going to get a lot more narrative surrounding what’s going on in Fiji and not overly tying game plot points to character attributions outside of the game.
On top of that, with two tribes of 10 players, we’re already seeing more pressure for forming the right alliances and strategizing early rather than simply hanging out around camp playing the “get to know you game.”
This is already setting us up for a gameplay heavy season with players being voted out based on actual strategy and in-game purposes, not simply because of friendships being made and people feeling bonded in small tribes early on.
Additionally, see the return to less consequential advantages—like Rob Antonson finding a hidden immunity idol without a Beware Advantage tied to it—makes it feel like we’re getting set up for a season with the majority of elimination and results coming out of genuine person-to-person gameplay and not because of fear of advantages or consequences of disadvantages.
What we didn’t like aboutSurvivor 51episode 1
While the marooning felt like we returned back to the classic eras ofSurvivor, Jeff moving the mat talk to right before the challenge wasn’t ideal.
About halfway through the episode—with the first hour feeling fast-paced and momentous—it felt like we suddenly halted things when Jeff felt the need to have his usual new era introductory conversations before the immunity challenge.
On top of that, it also felt a little awkward when he basically endorsed the Final Four fire-making challenge only to then ask the 20 present players whether or not they wanted to eliminate the challenge for their season. Only 5 players voted against keeping the twist that’s been permanently in play since season 35 and Jeff went on to explain that he knows what the players want and they want fire-making, idols, and twists.
He effectively told all the fans at home to shut up and stop complaining all the time about the parts of the game that they don’t like—because the players want it and that’s the only thing that matters in the end.
What we’ll remember most aboutSurvivor 51episode 1
There’s nothing quite like a live Tribal Council and while we’ve seen them over the last 10 seasons, they usually ended in the same consensus that fans at home knew was going to happen. We’re rarely been surprised by a player going home in the new era, but last week we truly did not know if it was going to be Aaliyah Puglia or Jenna Doore getting their torches snuffed.
And despite the solidity of the “Helicopter Alliance,” it was a breath of fresh air to see Jenna barely have to say anything in order to extensively manipulate Brady Booker into throwing Aaliyah under the bus instead of herself.
When both women played their shots in the dark, the tension at the Tribal Council could be felt through the screen and everyone at home was already rooting for one to stay and one to go. We haven’t had episode 1 players we’re rooting for like this in quite a while. Another breath of fresh air and heart-pounding moment as we waited for the votes to be read.
And, though we were sad to see Aaliyah go home, it was really telling for how the rest of the sason will go as Jenna was able to socially strategize her way out of the bottom. We can't wait to see what else she does this season!
Survivor 51episode 2, “Weaponized Honesty,” airs this Wednesday, September 30 at 8 p.m. on CBS and Paramount+.
Add us as a preferred source onGoogleLoading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations