Survivor: The best gross food challenge moments of all time

The Secret Weapon … Or Not – Season 7

For some people, eating gross foods isn’t difficult at all. In fact, Michelle in Pearl Islands had practically trained for it when she realized she’d be appearing on the show.

The Drake tribe had a plan figured out for the impending gross food challenge. Michelle was supposed to struggle to down whatever she was forced to eat, and that’d force the Morgan tribe into picking her for the tiebreaker. From there, she’d whoop her opponent’s butt, and Drake would win immunity! Huzzah! Seems pretty genius, right?

Well, the challenge consisted of a spinning wheel and Jeff Probst mixing gross things together in a blender and the contestants having to drink whatever nasty concoction was left. When Michelle went up for her turn, she didn’t struggle at all and downed her “smoothie” in less than ten seconds.

Obviously, when the tiebreaker came about, Morgan wasn’t fooled by Michelle because she didn’t do any acting. Instead, they picked Trish, who lost to Tijuana, and the Drake tribe was so angry with Michelle for not following through with the plan that she was voted off that very night.