3. “I will always wave my finger in your face!”
While the original Survivor had the Kelly/Sue fight near the end of the season, there wasn’t as heated of an argument as season two brought us with the finger wave fight. Let’s rewind a bit and give the backstory, shall we?
The Kucha tribe had won a reward challenge which gifted them with egg-laying chickens and a rooster. Kimmi Kappenberg, one of the Kucha members, was a vegetarian and therefore wanted no part of killing and eating the chickens.
Kimmi was pretty theatrical about all of this, making a scene whenever it was time to kill one of the chickens, and eventually, Alicia had had enough. She finally voiced her irritation with Kimmi’s theatrics.
The disagreement turned into an argument when Kimmi said she had a problem with Alicia’s attitude and the two just started going at it, screaming over each other for a solid minute. This gem of a fight gave us the famous “Don’t wave your finger in my face!” “I will ALWAYS wave my finger in your face!”
The finger wag was terrific, but the most underrated part of this fight was poor Elisabeth awkwardly standing in the middle as the two continued to scream at each other. The look on her face throughout the fight is priceless.
They don’t make Survivor fights quite like this anymore.