There are a bunch of former Survivor players competing on Survivor 50 in Fiji right now, but there are three others who are headed to the Scottish Highlands to film The Traitors season 4.
According to a report from Inside Survivor, fan favorite and host of Rob Has A Podcast, Rob Cesternino, will be playing The Traitors season 4, along with Survivor winners Natalie Anderson and Yam Yam Arocho.
The casting news comes from Reality TV News on X, so it's not officially official. We'll have to wait for Peacock to make the announcement, which should be arriving soon if the cast has already been revealed.
The Traitors US season 4 rumored cast 🧵#TheTraitors #TheTraitorsUS pic.twitter.com/vmlGGN68pq
— Reality TV News/Updates (@Realitytv__fan) June 12, 2025
According to the report, there are 13 other players competing on The Traitors season 4 and joining the Survivor stars. We shared the full cast:
- Johnny Weir
- Maura Higgins
- Eric Nam
- Porsha Williams
- Candace Dillard Bassett
- Lisa Rinna
- Monet X Change
- Mark Ballas
- Colton Underwood
- Donna Kelce
- Tiffany Mitchell
- Natalie Anderson
- Yam Yam Arocho
- Rob Cesternino
- Ian Terry
- Dorinda Medley
Survivor players have largely fared quite well on The Traitors. Cirie Fields actually won the first season of the series, while Sandra Diaz-Twine and Parvati Shallow performed well in season 2. On The Traitors season 3, which included Boston Rob, Tony Vlachos, and Jeremy Collins, the Survivor players were targeted pretty early in the game.
From a strategic perspective, Natalie should wipe the floor with that cast. After winning Survivor: San Juan Del Sur and performing well on Winners at War, she is definitely my pick to win The Traitors season 4, but I have a good feeling about Yam Yam and Rob, too. Yam Yam is a big personality who might rub some people the wrong way. Rob definitely has a certain charm about him that should help in the game, as well.
Overall, The Traitors is one of those games, like Survivor, that is so circumstantial. I know why Cirie was able to win season 1, and that's largely because of how the game played in her favor. She was picked as a traitor, but everyone knows her from Survivor as this legendary player, so she was able to use her strengths as an advantage. For Boston Rob, when he was a traitor in season 3, everyone suspected him of manipulating situations. He was able to work around it for a time, but it didn't really work out.
We'll just have to wait and see how Natalie, Rob, and Yam Yam will do when The Traitors season 4 premieres on Peacock. Right now, it looks like The Traitors season 4 will be released on Peacock in January 2026, but we'll continue to share updates as we find out!