You can’t win Survivor in the first half of the game, but you sure can lose it. The same goes from a viewer’s perspective.
When we see a cast of new or returning players hit the beach for the first time, the Survivor editors are already telling their stories. They typically build up the winner, or at least show their thought process, while perhaps making some of the early boots and non-finalists a bit more invisible.
Tiffany Ervin's early-season edit foreshadowed a losing game.
When Tiffany Ervin received fewer confessionals than celebrity Super Fan Zac Brown in the pre-merge portion of the game, a lot of astute viewers took notice. Her invisible edit signaled that while she may go far into the season, she really had no chance of winning the game, or even likely making it to the end.
The edit rectified that a bit as the season moved along after the merge, propping up Tiff as a threat via other castaways’ conversations and confessionals, but that was never truly shown to the viewers.
That’s why it appeared so obvious that Aubry Bracco was going to win Survivor 50 in the final few episodes, especially after Cirie Fields was voted out at the Final Six.
Aubry Bracco's Survivor 50 win was telegraphed heading into the finale.
Heading into the finale, Aubry was the heavy favorite, with Jonathan Young being presented as a contender as well. Joe Hunter looked to be a losing finalist again, Rizo Velovic’s path to winning was narrow at best, and Tiff was the clear Final Five vote out after her immunity win in the Final Six challenge saved her at the cost of her biggest ally the night before.
So, as Jeff Probst and the producers did everything they could to build up the neck-and-neck battle between Tiff and Jonathan at the Final Five immunity challenge, I, personally, never doubted what the outcome would be.
Despite being the closest Final Five challenge in Survivor history, there was no suspense. Perhaps more casual viewers or people who jumped in at the finale had their hearts beating a mile a minute, but Jonathan’s victory—at least in that challenge—felt inevitable, especially with Aubry, who had the most favorable edit, as the backup vote if Tiff was immune.
But imagine if the edit had built up Tiff as a true contender going into the finale. What if instead of getting a grand total of two confessionals in the first five episodes, they took a few away from Christian Hubicki’s 35 or Ozzy Lusth’s 34?
Aubry didn’t exactly have a huge hand in the pre-merge portion of the game, but they still showed what she was thinking with seven confessionals in the first two episodes and five more in the three episodes before the merge.
There is only so much screen time to go around in a 24-person cast, which is a conversation for another day, especially with so many great storytellers, but the editors could’ve built up the end of the game without taking too much away from the early episodes.
Add us as a preferred source on Google