Survivor Game Changers: Was Debbie’s Meltdown Enhanced By Editors?

While Debbie Wanner and Brad Culpepper did clash heads, the edit for Survivor Game Changers episode 5, “Dirty Deed” heightened the drama.

We all know that Survivor is heavily edited; there’s only so much entertainment you can derive out of up to 72 hours straight that can be condensed into a 42-minute package. Survivor Game Changers, no doubt, has had an odd edit so far, with Ciera Eastin and Tony Vlachos’ boots setting the tone for the season.

However, it appears as though the editing team has outright fabricated the sequence of events for Survivor Game Changers episode 5, pretending that two separate things happened in an order that doesn’t make any sense.

About 21:40 into the runtime of this episode, it’s Day 13 and we’ve already seen the Reward Challenge, Debbie direct anger post-challenge at Brad, Debbie blow up back at camp on what’s shown as Day 12 and Mana just sitting around camp. Tai thinks that an idol has been re-submitted back into the game, but there’s something about the shot where it’s revealed.

You see Hali Ford drinking water on the right? That’s the team immunity idol sitting in the tree right next to her head. The problem? As pointed out on Reddit, Tavua is supposed to have the immunity idol head at their tribe, as they won it last challenge. Mana wins it at the immunity challenge they’ve yet to show on television, creating a time paradox for viewers at home.

More from Season 34 Game Changers

• Survivor Game Changers wins GLAAD Awards’ Outstanding Reality Program
• Survivor Awards 2017: Best episode of the year
• Jeff Probst defends Survivor Game Changers’ outlandish idol count
• Big Brother 19’s handling of transphobia makes me proud of Survivor
• Survivor Game Changers: 5 Players we most want to play again

Despite me not seeing it before, having a clue that visible in a shot is sloppy work by the editors of Survivor Game Changers episode 5, and establishes the idea that they are willing to manipulate the events out or order to heighten the drama. While adding music and cuts to present a better context is accepted among reality television viewers, straight up misrepresenting how events unfolded shouldn’t be.

Now that it’s been established the show will do this, others have spotted inconsistencies within the episode. Remember at the Reward Challenge when Debbie failed the balance portion and proceeded to melt down in front of the Mana tribe on Day 12? There’s another shot that was noticed by another Reddit user that confirms the same immunity idol won after Day 13 was seen on footage declared as “Day 12.”

The idol’s base is perched in the same spot in the tree as above, in the very top-right corner of the screen, invalidating the timeline of Survivor Game Changers events as we know it.

Here is the most logical understanding of what happened as aired in episode 5, “Dirty Deed” compared to what likely happened in real life:

Related Story: Let’s Rank the Survivor Seasons by Their Locations

1. Mana blows the Reward Challenge on account of Debbie’s misplays on the balance beam
2. Debbie complains about Brad’s dictatorship and how he assigns tasks after the Day 13 immunity challenge, not after the reward challenge. Regardless, the editors insert it here to create drama.
3. Debbie blows up in anger against the Mana tribe after Mana wins immunity, yet it’s edited to reflect the reward challenge. Debbie’s confessionals indicate they come on Day 13, but it seems like they insert parts of Brad Culpepper’s Day 12 and Day 13 confessionals to contextualize why she would be angry.
4. Debbie complains about Hali taking a while on the balance beams in a way edited to look like she’s talking about the reward challenge. Instead, she’s talking about the immunity challenge, where Hali did play it slower than she did at the reward challenge.

I kind of understand why the editors for Survivor Game Changers episode 5 fudged the truth on the editing for this, and it’s mostly based on what’s ahead. With a tribe swap coming next episode, and most of the time after immunity focusing on J.T., Sandra and Michaela, having this blow up happen alongside J.T. saying Michaela needed to be babysat would completely destroy his narrative. They need to show it early on in the episode as not to overshadow J.T.’s inevitable exit.

What’s most disappointing is that you don’t need to manipulate the events to portray Debbie as over the top negative. She’s still claiming to be a gymnast of ten years, saying she doesn’t get pissed in the process of being pissed and yelling at people in their faces. This edit does, however, make the use of the flashback to call Debbie out suspect and lessens Brad’s subjective authority when picking roles as the leader.

Next: Survivor Game Changers: Ranking All 33 Previous Seasons

It just goes to show you that even in Survivor Game Changers, a sequence of events may not be as sequential as once thought.