3 Survivor 48 players voted out way too soon

Survivor 48 is really fun, but it would be more fun if these three players were still in the game.
“The Get to Know You Game” – Eighteen new castaways will be abandoned on the breathtaking islands of Fiji, where they must battle it out for the $1 million prize. Tribes must claim victory in the first challenge of the season to earn essential camp supplies. Then, first impressions go a long way as tribemates quickly make connections and size each other up, on the two-hour season premiere of SURVIVOR, Wednesday, Feb. 26 (8:00-10:00 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network, and streaming on
“The Get to Know You Game” – Eighteen new castaways will be abandoned on the breathtaking islands of Fiji, where they must battle it out for the $1 million prize. Tribes must claim victory in the first challenge of the season to earn essential camp supplies. Then, first impressions go a long way as tribemates quickly make connections and size each other up, on the two-hour season premiere of SURVIVOR, Wednesday, Feb. 26 (8:00-10:00 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network, and streaming on | CB

Survivor 48 is one of the best casts we've seen in a long time. Inevitably, we've already had to say goodbye to some of the best players from this cast. That's just how Survivor works; good players with great personalities get voted out of the game every single week.

With only a few episodes in Survivor 48 left and five players left to be voted out before Final Tribal Council, I shared the three players voted out way too soon. I don't know about you, but I really wish we got to see these three players play a little more.

Thomas Krottinger

The House Party's Over
“The House Party’s Over” – An unexpected twist for the castaways sends the trajectory of their games into an all-new direction. An undercover alliance in the losing tribe leads to a shocking tribal council on SURVIVOR, Wednesday, March 19 (8:00-9:30 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network, and available to stream on Paramount+ (live and on demand for Paramount+ with SHOWTIME subscribers, or on demand for Paramount+ Essential subscribers the day after the episode airs)*. Jeff Probst serves as | CB

Thomas Krottinger is the Survivor 48 player I was most disappointed to see voted out so early. Thomas only made it a few episodes before he was knocked out in a stunning immunity idol play by Kyle Fraser following the tribe swap. Thomas started the game on the Lagi tribe, and had they not swapped tribes because the Vula tribe was losing so badly every week, Thomas probably would have ended up making the merge in a super strong alliance that includes some combination of Shauhin Davari, Joe Hunter, and Bianca Roses. Oh, what could have been.

Thomas clearly had some strategic acumen, which we saw in his short time in the game, but socially, I think he could read people so well. He basically called Kyle and Kamilla Karthigesu's bluff, but he didn't have a chance to really show everything that he was capable of doing in the game. And, that's disappointing for fans. Honestly, I just would have enjoyed Thomas's confessionals throughout the season commenting on all of the drama. That's what really missed out on as viewers.

Bianca Roses

Humble Traits
“Humble Traits” – A frantic idol hunt could save or ruin one castaway’s game. A castaway’s quick decision making must outlast the test of time when three castaways are sent on a journey. Then, castaways take a leap of faith in their second immunity challenge where they must trust their tribemates to beat out their competition, on SURVIVOR, Wednesday, March 5 (8:00-9:30 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network, and streaming on Paramount+ (live and on-demand for Paramount+ with SHOWTIME | CB

Bianca Roses is another player I really feel like was voted out way too soon. And like Thomas, it was almost exclusively because of the tribe swap. Bianca went from being protected on the Lagi tribe to basically on her own and in the middle of two Vula players (Sai Hughley and Cedrek McFadden) and two Civa players (Mitch Guerra and Chrissy Sarnowsky). Biance was chosen for a Journey, and she lost her vote, so the show basically doomed her from the jump. No one should be forced to potentially lose their vote on a tribe of five people. It's a ridiculous flaw in the game.

Anyway, Bianca scrambled, and she almost made it happen. Instead, Cedrek turned on her after finding out she didn't have a vote, looped in Chrissy, and made the first 2-1-1 vote in Survivor history happen.

Ultimately, Bianca was set up to succeed in Survivor until she wasn't. We were all robbed of many, many awesome reactions from Bianca and Thomas and probably some good gameplay, too.

Sai Hughley

Committing to the Bit
“Committing to the Bit” – Castaways must fly blind during the immunity challenge, leaving one tribe with tribal council in their sights. The rising tensions within the losing tribe culminate in a historic tribal council, on SURVIVOR, Wednesday, March 12 (8:00-9:30 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network, and available to stream on Paramount+*. Jeff Probst serves as host and executive producer. Pictured: Saiounia “Sai” Hughley. Photo: Robert Voets/CBS ©2024 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights | CB

Sai Hughley just missed joining the Survivor 48 jury. Had Cedrek been voted out ahead of her in the split Tribal Council, Sai would be sitting on the jury, chilling at Ponderosa, and making us laugh with her absolutely brutal reactions to what was happening at Tribal Council.

Sai played Survivor with an intensity that I don't think anyone else is playing the game with this season. She spoke her mind, and while it got her into trouble, it was amazing for viewers to get that unfiltered assessment of what was happening in the game. I laughed so hard when she interrupted Stephanie Berger during the first Tribal Council, and it got even better throughout the rest of the season.

It would have been great to see, if things played out a little differently, if Sai had been able to make it through the merge with a group of allies. Clearly, Sai had an aptitude for the game, but because she was on the bottom so often, we didn't get a chance to really see exactly how she could maneuver in the game strategically.

So, those are the three players who were voted out of Survivor 48 too soon. I'm sure we'll see a few more additions in the next few weeks as Survivor 48 comes down to the wire.